Notes

Criticism of the provided perspective on polygamy in Islam may include the following points:

1. Gender Equality Critics argue that the practice of polygamy in Islam is not in line with the principles of gender equality. Allowing men to have multiple wives while restricting women to one husband may be seen as perpetuating unequal power dynamics in relationships.

2. Consent and Agency The perspective doesn't explicitly address the issue of the consent of the women involved. Critics argue that the emphasis should be on the free and informed consent of all parties involved in a marriage, and not merely on the man's ability to provide for them.

3. Social Stigma The perspective acknowledges that polygamy is often abused, but it doesn't delve into the potential social stigma and emotional challenges that women in polygamous marriages might face. Critics argue that these factors can lead to emotional distress, jealousy, and an overall negative impact on the well-being of the individuals involved.

4. Monogamous Alternatives Critics may suggest that there are alternative solutions to problems such as infertility or illness within a marriage that do not involve taking additional spouses. For example, seeking medical assistance for infertility issues or providing support for an ill spouse without resorting to polygamy.

5.
Adaptability of Religious Principles Some critics argue that religious principles should be adaptable to changing social norms.
In a modern context where monogamous relationships are widely accepted, the practice of polygamy is considered outdated and incompatible with modern views on marriage and equality.

6. Limitation of Choice for Women The perspective implies that the three options for unmarried women are either remaining single, engaging in unacceptable behavior, or accepting a polygamous marriage. Critics may argue that these limited choices do not empower women to make decisions based on their personal desires and values.

7. Male Fairness Assumption This perspective assumes that a man who chooses polygamy can be fair and impartial with his wife.
Critics may argue that this assumption overlooks the potential for favoritism, inequality, and unequal distribution of resources among wives..

8. Reliance on Traditional Roles The perspective seems to rely on traditional gender roles and assumes that the primary role of a woman is to be a wife and mother. Critics may argue that this perspective limits the autonomy and aspirations of women, relegating them to predefined roles within society.