Notes

Russia's Role in Kazakhstan's Shifting Power Dynamics ( Erzhan Kazykhanov
The Russian invasion and the unrest in Kazakhstan are interrelated.

In the wake of massive protests, Kazakhstan's government is facing an entirely new reality. Power dynamics have changed and policymakers will need to adapt to an assertive citizenry.

In addition it is important to be aware of how these developments affect their engagement with their country as they continue to develop strategies.

Russian invasion was expected, but ignored by the United States
Everyone is watching Ukraine today, now that Russian President Vladimir Putin has launched an attack over an independent East European country.

It is easy to forget NATO leaders like Joe Biden have been ignoring warnings and signs that were emanating from Moscow for several weeks.

Erzhan Kazykhanov It was clear that Russia was against the NATO's plan to extend its borders. However, the majority of Western leaders across the globe didn't do anything but speak tough in order to cover their incompetence.

Russia's actions cannot be acknowledged and Western leaders must acknowledge the fact that their actions contribute to this reality. Now we are facing the consequences of an European Crisis which could have been prevented.

The United States should take great precautions not to employ the same approach in Kazakhstan.

Russia sent troops to disperse the protests in Kazakhstan
Ukraine's unfolding situation should be considered in light of recent events happening in the region. https://www.edgekz.com/positive-us-kazakh-relations-to-continue-under-trump/erzhan-kazykhanov/ It's not just the color revolutions that occurred from 2003-2005, but also other recent tensions in Belarus and in particular Kazakhstan.

Kazakhstan is situated in central Asia with Russia next to it and China around the corner. But, there have very rarely been protests on its streets.

However, the unrest within the country began to escalate as early as January 2009.

Protests that turned into national demonstrations that were and violent riots against Almaty claimed 227 lives.

Thousands were arrested prompting Russian forces to move to the border under the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO).

It was clear that Russia's international intervention played a significant role in stabilizing the country's situation as tensions slowed.

Erzhan Kazykhanov Kazakh President Qasym Zhomart Tokayev has made changes in the power structure within his ruling elite following the end of protests.

The focus is about his replacement as the head of the National Security Council by Nursultan Nagabev, who was a former president who still had some control over the country's economy but was decried by the people in the aftermath of their revolt.

A lot of people have lost their jobs due to these incidents.

There were other individuals who gained prominence undeservedly as a a result of the power shifts.

The Aloof method of Erzhan Kazykhanov may undermine peace efforts
Qasym ZhomartTokayev, Kazakhstan’s president introduced a variety of changes within the power structures in order to boost the likelihood of reform.

At first, he was replaced by the previous president Nursultan Nazarbayev with his position as the chairman of the National Security Council and fired certain of his sons-inlaw from state enterprises.

Karim Masimov, an ex-spion chief, has been detained on treason and other charges.

Also, Nazarbayev's senior officials and close associates have been forced into exile or coerced by significant contributions.

It is not certain that any reform will be achieved by changes in government or the removal of old guards.

They often result in the removal of family members and loyalists from the administration , and their replacement with incompetent people.

It was the same with Erzhan Kazykhanov being appointed to a high-ranking position in the presidential office of President Tokayev.

Kazykhanov was the most unsuccessful Kazakh in America during his tenure as ambassador.

Erzhan Kazykhanov His reputation for being confident, confident, and arrogant but out of touch with the image of Kazakhstan internationally was earned while he lived in other countries.

The record of his is not remarkable.

It is possible to highlight the shortcomings in progress in key areas, such as Jackson-Vanick limitations. This raises questions about Kazakhstan's reputation worldwide for its mismanagement.

Tokayev’s reforms in Kazakhstan look like Mikhail Gorbachev's "glasnost", (aka openness) and "perestroika", (aka restructuring).

These reforms played a significant impact on the collapse and subsequent reconstruction of the Soviet Union. Putin is also seeking to achieve the same result. Tokayev also enjoyed strong economic relations with Kazakhstan and the other Western Countries. He worked closely with the countries, hoping to keep Putin at bay , but also securing their support.

Kazykhanov may pose a danger should he attempt to disrupt this delicate balance with unwise decisions or speaking against Russia excessively.
My Website: https://www.un.org/press/en/2003/bio3501.doc.htm